Annual vs. Perennial Herbs: Choosing the Best for Your Herb Garden

Growing an herb garden is one of the most rewarding gardening experiences, offering fresh flavors for cooking, fragrant foliage, and even natural remedies. But when selecting herbs for your garden, it's important to understand the difference between annual and perennial herbs. Knowing which herbs return year after year and which ones need to be replanted each season will help you design a thriving, productive herb garden.

‍

Understanding the Difference: Annual vs. Perennial Herbs

‍

Annual Herbs

Annual herbs complete their life cycle in one growing season, meaning they grow, flower, produce seeds, and then die. This means you’ll need to replant them each year. However, some annuals readily self-seed, meaning they drop seeds that may sprout the following season on their own.

Common Annual Herbs:

• Basil: A warm-season favorite, basil thrives in full sun and well-draining soil. Pinch back flowers to encourage continuous leaf production.
• Cilantro: Grows quickly in cooler weather but bolts (goes to seed) in the heat. Try succession planting for a longer harvest.
• Dill: Loved for its feathery foliage and flavorful seeds, dill prefers full sun and well-drained soil.

Pro Tip:

If you love fresh basil or cilantro, stagger your plantings every few weeks to extend your harvest throughout the season!

‍

Perennial Herbs

Perennial herbs return year after year, going dormant in winter and regrowing in spring. These herbs are a great investment in any herb garden since they provide long-term harvests with minimal effort.

Common Perennial Herbs:

• Rosemary: A hardy, fragrant herb that thrives in full sun and well-draining soil. Protect in harsh winters in colder zones.
• Thyme: A low-maintenance herb that spreads well and is drought-tolerant once established.
• Oregano: Perfect for Mediterranean-inspired gardens, oregano loves sunny, dry conditions.
• Sage: A flavorful culinary herb that also produces beautiful purple flowers.
• Mint: A vigorous grower that spreads aggressively—consider planting in containers to keep it from taking over your garden.
• Chives: Easy to grow, with mild onion-flavored leaves that return every spring.

Pro Tip:

Harvest perennial herbs regularly to keep them from becoming woody and overgrown.

‍

** Keep in mind that some herbs are not fully hardy (or perennial) depending on your hardiness zone. For example, here in Northwest Arkansas, Thyme, Rosemary, and Lavender may not come back after a particularly cold winter.  

‍

Tips for Growing a Thriving Herb Garden

1. Choose the Right Location

Most herbs thrive in full sun (at least 6 hours of direct sunlight per day). However, some herbs, like parsley and mint, prefer partial shade, especially in hotter climates. If you are planting mint or oregano, be sure to use a container – or else it will take over your whole garden! 

2. Use Well-Draining Soil

Herbs don’t like wet feet! Make sure your soil is loose, well-draining, and rich in organic matter. If you have heavy clay soil, consider raised beds or containers.

3. Water Smartly

Generally, herbs prefer drier conditions and should be watered sparingly once established. Annual herbs like basil and cilantro will require a bit more water. 

4. Harvest Frequently & Pinch Off Blooms

Regular harvesting encourages more growth! Trim herbs often, especially before they start flowering, to keep plants full and productive. Once you see blooms, pinch them off! If you don’t, your herbs will “bolt” and it can affect the taste. 

‍

The Best of Both Worlds

The best herb gardens include a mix of annuals and perennials for long-term enjoyment. Whether you’re growing herbs in containers, raised beds, or alongside vegetables, having a diverse selection will keep your garden productive and flavorful all season long.

‍

Ready to start your herb garden? Come see us to choose your favorites, grab some good soil, and get planting! 🌿

‍